Counter Offer Email Templates for Salary Negotiation (With Examples)

Six counter offer email templates for salary negotiation, with what the research says makes a counter work and the mistakes that cost people money.

Her Success Coach helps women leaders build confidence, overcome self-doubt, and lead with clarity. Cambridge-trained, evidence-based coaching for senior women in tech, business, and finance.

You have an offer, and you want to ask for more. Writing the counter offer email is often the hardest part: you want to sound confident without sounding ungrateful, and specific without sounding like an ultimatum.

This guide gives you counter offer email templates you can adapt, explains what the research says makes a counter work, and covers the mistakes that quietly cost people money.

Should you counter by email or by phone?

If you can, make the counter in a short call and then confirm it by email the same day. Tone carries better in conversation, and you can hear how the other side reacts. The email then does two jobs: it puts your request in writing, and it gives the hiring manager something they can forward to whoever approves the budget.

If the recruiter has only communicated by email, or a call is not possible, an email counter is perfectly normal. The templates below work either way.

What makes a counter offer work

Four findings from negotiation research shape every template in this guide.

  • Asking rarely costs you the offer. In a 2024 study, hiring managers reported withdrawing an average of 1.73 offers, out of 26.9 extended in their careers, after a candidate negotiated. Candidates expected withdrawals to be far more common than that (Hart et al., Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2024).
  • Name a precise number. The first number on the table strongly predicts where the deal lands, and precise numbers such as £87,500 anchor more strongly than round ones such as £90,000, because they signal that you have done the research (Galinsky and Mussweiler, 2001; Mason et al., 2013).
  • Explain why the request is fair. In experiments, women were penalised more than men for negotiating in the same way. When women explained why their request was legitimate and showed they cared about the working relationship, they got better outcomes and were seen just as positively (Bowles, Babcock and Lai, 2007; Bowles and Babcock, 2013).
  • Offer options, not ultimatums. Proposing two or three packages you would be equally happy with created stronger anchors and a more cooperative conversation than a single demand (Leonardelli et al., 2019).

So a good counter offer email is warm, gives a precise number, explains the reason, and makes it easy to say yes.

Template 1: Asking for time and the full offer

Send this before you counter. It buys you time to do your research, and makes sure you are negotiating the whole package, not just the salary.

Subject: Thank you, [Role] offer

Dear [Name],

Thank you so much for the offer. I really enjoyed meeting the team and I'm excited about the role.

Could you send me the full details in writing, including the bonus, pension, benefits and start date? I'd like to review everything properly and will come back to you by [day and time].

Best wishes, [Your name]

Template 2: The salary counter offer email

This is the core template. Replace every bracket, and keep it short.

Subject: [Role] offer, following up

Dear [Name],

Thank you again for the offer. I'm very keen to join and to [specific thing you're excited to work on].

Having reviewed the scope of the role, including [one or two key responsibilities], and what similar roles at this level are paying in [location], I'd like to ask for a base salary of [precise number].

I want to start on a footing that feels fair to both of us, so I'm open to talking through how we get there. I look forward to hearing from you by [day].

Best wishes, [Your name]

Why it works: it opens with commitment, gives a legitimate reason, names one precise number and closes by inviting a joint solution. There is no apology and no range for them to pick the bottom of.

Template 3: Counter offer with two options

Use this when the employer has said the base is tight, or when you want to make it easier for them to find a yes.

Subject: [Role] offer, two options that would work for me

Dear [Name],

Thank you for going back to the team. To make this easier, here are two packages I'd be equally happy with. Either would let me accept this week:

Option A: base salary of [number], with the bonus and benefits as offered. Option B: base salary of [lower number], plus a signing bonus of [amount] and a salary review at six months against agreed goals.

I hope one of these works on your side. I'm really looking forward to getting started.

Best wishes, [Your name]

Template 4: When you have a competing offer

Only use this if the other offer is real. Inventing one damages trust and can backfire if you are asked for details.

Subject: [Role] offer

Dear [Name],

I want to be transparent with you. I've received another offer at [amount], but this role is my first choice because of [genuine reason].

If you're able to reach a base of [number], I'd be ready to accept.

Best wishes, [Your name]

Template 5: When the base salary is fixed

If they have told you the salary band is fixed, move the conversation to the rest of the package.

Subject: [Role] offer, the wider package

Dear [Name],

Thank you for explaining the salary band, I understand. Would it be possible to look at other parts of the package instead? A signing bonus of [amount], or a salary review at six months against agreed goals, would close most of the gap for me.

I'm still very keen to join, and I'm confident we can find something that works.

Best wishes, [Your name]

Other terms that are often easier to move than base pay include title, start date, holiday, a guaranteed first-year bonus, pension contribution, a learning budget and a written hybrid working pattern.

Template 6: Accepting the final offer

Once you agree, confirm every term in writing before you sign. Verbal promises about reviews or bonuses are easy to lose when people change roles.

Subject: Accepting the [Role] offer

Dear [Name],

Thank you for working through this with me. I'm delighted to accept.

To confirm what we agreed: a base salary of [number], [bonus], [other terms] and a start date of [date]. Could you send the updated contract reflecting these terms? I'll sign as soon as I receive it.

Best wishes, [Your name]

Counter offer email mistakes to avoid

  • Apologising. "I'm sorry to ask, but..." tells the reader you think the request is not legitimate.
  • Giving a range. If you write "£80,000 to £90,000", expect to be offered £80,000.
  • A round number with no reason. "£100,000" with no explanation looks like a guess.
  • Reopening everything. Pick the one or two things that matter most. A long list reads as unhappiness with the whole offer.
  • Accepting on the spot when they come back. "Thank you, that's a real step forward. Let me look at it in writing" is always available to you.

How to work out your number

Before you send any counter offer email, decide three numbers and write them down:

  1. Your walk-away point: the lowest total package you would accept, given your best alternative.
  2. Your target: an ambitious but defensible number at the upper end of your market data.
  3. Your opening number: slightly above your target, and precise.

For market data, use at least three sources: national salary statistics, recruiter salary guides, advertised pay ranges for similar roles and, often most useful, conversations with recruiters or people in similar roles.

Get the full negotiation kit

If you have an offer on the table right now, the Offer Negotiation Kit takes you further than this guide: a 48 hour plan, a numbers worksheet, a fill-in template for your relational ask, word-for-word scripts for the call and for difficult moments such as "the budget is fixed" or "we need an answer today", and email templates for every stage. It's £39 and you can download it straight away. For the research behind this approach, read salary negotiation for women.

Continue reading

  • How to Get on a Board as a Woman
  • How to Get Promoted Without Self-Promotion
  • How to Handle Redundancy with Dignity

What you will find here

This page is part of the Her Success Coach resource library — a collection of practical articles, frameworks, and coaching programmes designed for women leaders. Explore in-depth guides on leadership confidence, career transitions, executive presence, imposter syndrome, delegation, strategic thinking, and difficult conversations at work. Book a 30-minute Clarity Session to discuss your goals, or join an on-demand course to develop the skills you need at your own pace.

About Her Success Coach

Iveta Dulova is an executive and leadership coach for women with a decade of experience in global technology and a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge. She works with women managers, directors, and founders across technology, financial services, and consulting who want to build executive presence, negotiate with confidence, and build a career that reflects their values rather than their fears.

Explore more

  • Home
  • About Iveta
  • Coaching services
  • Articles and resources
  • Book a Clarity Session
  • The Confident Leader course
  • Contact

Online executive coaching for clients in London, Toronto, Singapore and Sydney.

Research