"Too Aggressive" and "Not Assertive Enough": What to Do With Contradictory Feedback

Why women leaders are told to push harder and to soften in the same review, what the research says about the double bind, and a practical way to respond.

Her Success Coach helps women leaders build confidence, overcome self-doubt, and lead with clarity. Cambridge-trained, evidence-based coaching for senior women in tech, business, and finance.

One review. Two comments. Your manager wants you to be more decisive and push back harder. A peer says you can be forceful and shut discussion down. It is tempting to conclude that the feedback is worthless. Usually it is telling you something precise, once you know how to read it.

Why it happens

Expectations of leaders and expectations of women pull in different directions. Decisive and assertive fit the first set. Warm and collaborative fit the second. A woman who is assertive can meet one expectation while breaking the other.

The best summary of the evidence is a 2016 meta-analysis by Melissa Williams and Larissa Tiedens, which combined 71 studies. Three findings matter in practice.

  1. Women were penalised more than men for the same dominant behaviour, and the penalty fell on how much they were liked. Their competence ratings did not drop.
  2. The penalty appeared for explicit dominance, such as direct demands. It did not appear for implicit signals such as steady eye contact, posture and a strong voice.
  3. The overall effect was small. The floor is tilted. It is not a wall.

Written reviews show the same pattern. Stanford researchers who coded managers' reviews at a Fortune 500 technology company found that men and women were described as equally able technically, while women were more often viewed as too aggressive and taking charge was rewarded more in men's ratings. The largest differences were in comments about personality, potential and exceptional performance.

The Center for Talent Innovation found that executive presence feedback to women and people of colour is so often contradictory that 81 per cent are unclear how to act on it.

Step one: sort the comments by setting

Contradictory comments almost always come from different rooms. Write each comment down with the meeting, the audience and the kind of moment it came from.

A common result looks like this. "Be more decisive" comes from negotiations with other teams, where you agreed to unrealistic requests to keep the peace. "Forceful" comes from your own team's discussions, where you give your view first and the debate ends.

Seen this way, the answer is not a midpoint between too much and not enough. It is a different habit in each room.

Step two: choose your channel

I use a simple map with two questions. Is the signal explicit, meaning words that claim authority, or implicit, meaning voice, pace and posture? And whose interest is it visibly serving, yours or other people's?

  • Implicit and for others. Steady presence while protecting the team or the work. Little backlash, a great deal of authority. Most of your influence can live here.
  • Implicit and for yourself. Holding your space when challenged. The research suggests little penalty.
  • Explicit and for others. Direct requests and refusals on behalf of your team, customers or the organisation. Negotiation research finds women face little or no penalty when advocating for others.
  • Explicit and for yourself. Direct demands on your own behalf. This is where the double bind bites hardest. It is sometimes exactly right, and it needs the most preparation.

Step three: move the sentence, keep the message

Most pushback can be moved from the last category to the third without becoming dishonest.

Before After
"No, we're not doing that." "I can't commit my team to this quarter without risking the migration three product lines depend on."
"Don't interrupt me." "Let me finish this point, because it affects the decision."
"I'm not taking on another project." "If my team takes this on, the security work slips by a quarter. I don't think that's the right trade."

The second versions are not softer. They are harder to argue with, because they are about the work.

Step four: ask the comparison question

If a comment still looks unfair after sorting, ask calmly: "When a colleague pushes back in the same way, how is it read?" You are not accusing anyone. You are checking whether the standard is the same.

A word on fairness

None of this is fair, and fixing it is the organisation's job. Structured criteria and specific feedback reduce the room that impressions have to operate in. Until then, you deserve tools that work on a tilted floor.

Next step: Chapter 2 of Executive Presence, Decoded covers the Authority Map in full. The free Presence Self-Assessment includes an Influence score. To decode other phrases, use the executive presence feedback translator.

Sources

  • Williams, M. J. and Tiedens, L. Z. (2016). The subtle suspension of backlash: A meta-analysis of penalties for women's implicit and explicit dominance behavior. Psychological Bulletin, 142(2), 165 to 197.
  • Correll, S. J., Weisshaar, K. R., Wynn, A. T. and Wehner, J. D. (2020). Inside the black box of organizational life. American Sociological Review, 85(6). Stanford summary
  • Amanatullah, E. T. and Morris, M. W. (2010). Negotiating gender roles. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 98(2), 256 to 267.
  • Center for Talent Innovation (2012). Executive Presence: key findings. coqual.org

This guide is part of our series on executive presence. See all the guides, and how one-to-one support works, on our executive presence coaching page.

Continue reading

  • CTO Coaching: Support for Women in the Top Tech Role
  • How to Deal with a Micromanager: Strategies That Actually Work
  • How to Deal with a Toxic Boss: A Professional's Survival Guide

What you will find here

This page is part of the Her Success Coach resource library — a collection of practical articles, frameworks, and coaching programmes designed for women leaders. Explore in-depth guides on leadership confidence, career transitions, executive presence, imposter syndrome, delegation, strategic thinking, and difficult conversations at work. Book a 30-minute Clarity Session to discuss your goals, or join an on-demand course to develop the skills you need at your own pace.

About Her Success Coach

Iveta Dulova is an executive and leadership coach for women with a decade of experience in global technology and a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge. She works with women managers, directors, and founders across technology, financial services, and consulting who want to build executive presence, negotiate with confidence, and build a career that reflects their values rather than their fears.

Explore more

  • Home
  • About Iveta
  • Coaching services
  • Articles and resources
  • Book a Clarity Session
  • The Confident Leader course
  • Contact

Online executive coaching for clients in London, Toronto, Singapore and Sydney.

Research