This book is written for a particular woman. She is good at her work, often very good. She has been promoted for expertise: the strongest engineer, the sharpest analyst, the lawyer or finance lead everyone turns to, the manager who knows the business better than anyone. Somewhere on the way up she received a piece of feedback that sounded important and meant almost nothing: you need to work on your executive presence.
If that is you, this book is meant to be useful on a Tuesday morning. Each chapter takes one part of presence, explains what the research actually shows, and ends with tools you can use in your next meeting. I have tried to keep it practical, specific and honest about what is your job to change and what is not.
A note on the stories. The client stories in this book are composites. Each one draws on patterns I have seen many times in coaching, with names, details and settings invented so that no real person can be identified. Where I describe my own experience, from fourteen years in software engineering and product leadership, it is my own.
A note on the evidence. I have cited research throughout, and the Notes and Sources section at the back lists each study. Psychology has spent the last decade testing its own famous findings, and some did not survive. Where a popular idea has been weakened, I say so. You deserve advice built on what holds up.
The first time someone told me I needed more presence, I was sitting in a small meeting room with a whiteboard still covered in someone else's architecture diagram. I had just led a migration that half the engineering organisation had said could not be done in a quarter. It was done in a quarter. My manager was pleased with the work. Then he paused, and said that for the next level, people would need to "see more presence" from me.
I asked what that meant. He thought about it for a while and said, "You know. Gravitas. People need to feel you're in charge."
I went home and did what engineers do. I searched for a specification. I found articles about standing tall, lowering my voice, dressing for the job I wanted, and speaking with confidence. None of it told me what to do differently in the planning meeting on Thursday. Most of it seemed to assume that the problem was me.
It took me years, a career change into product management, and later my training as a coach, to understand what had happened in that room. My manager was describing something real. He was also describing it so vaguely that I could not act on it. And the vagueness was not an accident of one conversation. It is a pattern, it falls more heavily on women, and it can be decoded.
That is what this book is for.
Executive presence is the judgement other people make about whether you are someone who can be trusted with more. More scope, more people, more money, more risk. It is a prediction about the future made from evidence in the present, and the evidence is mostly how you act when it matters.
The most widely used research on the topic comes from the economist Sylvia Ann Hewlett and the Center for Talent Innovation, now Coqual. In 2012 her team surveyed senior executives and asked which qualities signalled leadership potential. The answers grouped into three pillars: how you act, which they called gravitas; how you speak, or communication; and how you look, or appearance. Gravitas dominated. Two thirds of the senior executives named it as the most important part, against just over a quarter for communication and only five per cent for appearance.
That last number is worth a moment. Much of the advice aimed at women about presence is about appearance: the right jacket, the right shoes, the right haircut. The executives in that survey said appearance mattered least. Hewlett added a caution: appearance works as a first filter. Get it badly wrong for your context and people stop listening before they reach your substance. Get it roughly right and it stops being the point.
When Hewlett repeated the survey ten years later, the picture had shifted. Confidence and decisiveness still mattered. Inclusiveness had risen to the top three traits of gravitas. Listening to learn now counted as a communication strength. Authenticity, which had barely registered in 2012, was newly valued. The definition of presence is not fixed. It moves with what organisations need, and what they need now is less theatre and more judgement.
Gravitas, how you act: two thirds (67%). Communication, how you speak: just over a quarter (28%). Appearance, how you look: 5%.
The figure shows how the senior executives in Hewlett's 2012 survey answered when asked which pillar mattered most. Gravitas dominated. Appearance came a distant third, though, as Hewlett notes, it works as a first filter.
Presence is not extroversion. Some of the most commanding leaders I have worked with speak rarely and carefully. Presence is not volume, height, or a deep voice. It is not a performance of certainty about things you do not know. And it is not the same as being liked, though as we will see, for women the two are tangled together in ways that deserve honesty.
Presence is also not a personality transplant. If you finish this book trying to become someone else, I have failed. The aim is to make what you already know and already are visible to the people making decisions about you.
Men get told to work on their presence too. But the research shows three things that make this feedback different for women.
First, women receive it more vaguely. Studies of performance reviews have repeatedly found that women get more feedback about their style and personality, and less feedback tied to business outcomes. Vague feedback cannot be acted on, which means it cannot be closed.
Second, the target moves. Behaviour that reads as confident in a man can read as abrasive in a woman, and behaviour that reads as collaborative in a woman can read as lacking authority. Researchers call this the double bind. It is real, measurable and frustrating, and Chapter 2 is devoted to it.
Third, women are more often promoted for expertise and then judged on presence. The move from being the person with the answers to being the person who sets direction is hard for everyone. It is harder when the habits that made you successful, such as thoroughness, humility and precision, start to be read as hesitation.
None of this means women lack presence. It means the way presence is judged, described and developed has been built around a narrower template than the one you fit. You can widen that template. You can also learn to work skilfully inside it while it widens.
Part One, Decode It, is about understanding what is being asked of you. Chapter 1 shows how to turn vague feedback into specific behaviours. Chapter 2 deals with the double bind. Chapter 3 is about the shift from expert to leader, where many presence problems actually begin. Chapter 4 is for anyone who is often the only woman in the room.
Part Two, Build It, covers the skills. How you structure what you say. How you use your voice, body and the space in a room, including a virtual one. How you stay steady under pressure. How you disagree with senior people without damaging the relationship. How you talk about your own work without shrinking it. And what to do with impostor thoughts, which turn out to be less damaging than their reputation.
Part Three, Use It, is about the organisation around you. How decisions are actually made, often before the meeting starts. How to protect your time from work that will never be rewarded. How to build sponsorship. How to handle hard conversations, lead when nobody has the answers and make the most of your first ninety days at a new level. And how to make all of this sustainable and your own.
Each chapter ends with a section called This Week, a short set of actions small enough to try immediately. At the back you will find a toolkit with scripts, questions and a ninety-day plan.
Read it in order, or go straight to the chapter that stings. Either works.
Each of the seventeen chapters introduces at least one named framework, shown as a diagram. They are designed to be remembered under pressure: most have three to five parts and a short name. You will find them all together in the Presence Toolkit at the back.
Each chapter also includes a second client story, a short self-check, and a section called Coach's Notes, which covers the traps I see most often when people put the ideas into practice.
If you want a starting point, complete the Presence Self-Assessment at the back of the book before you read further. It takes about ten minutes and will show you which chapters to read first.