Her Success Coach Research · Evidence Review No. 3

The Confidence Gap: What the Evidence Actually Says

Do women really lack confidence, how much does it matter, and why does the same confidence pay off differently for women and men?

Iveta Dulova · Diploma in Coaching and Leadership, University of Cambridge · November 2026

Definition

What is the confidence gap?

The confidence gap is the claim that women are less confident in their abilities than equally capable men, and that this holds back their careers. The idea was popularised in 2014.1 Research supports part of it: women do rate their own performance lower than men who perform equally well.3, 4 But the gap explains only a small share of differences in career outcomes, and confidence is not rewarded in the same way for women.7, 8

About this paper. This is a narrative evidence review of research on the confidence gap between women and men at work. It summarises published findings in plain English and does not report new data. Every figure in the charts is taken from the cited source and can be checked against the reference list.

01 Executive summary

"Be more confident" may be the most common piece of advice given to ambitious women. It rests on a real finding, but the popular version stretches that finding a long way. The evidence points to a narrower problem and to different solutions.

Five findings

  1. Women rate their own performance lower than equally performing men. In a large set of experiments, women and men scored the same on a maths and science test, yet women rated their performance about 25% lower. The gap remained even with no incentive to self-promote, and it appeared as early as the sixth grade.3, 12
  2. It shapes choices. In a classic experiment with no difference in performance, 73% of men chose to be paid through competition against 35% of women, partly because men were more overconfident.4
  3. The most quoted statistic is weakly sourced. The claim that women apply for jobs only when they meet 100% of the requirements comes from an unpublished internal report. When asked directly, most people who held back said they thought they would not be hired, not that they could not do the job.2
  4. Confidence explains a small part of the gap at the top. A long-term study following people from childhood found men's greater overconfidence explained 5% to 11% of the gender gap in holding a top job at age 42.7
  5. Confidence does not pay women in the same way. At a technology company, appearing self-confident turned into influence for men directly. High-performing women gained influence only when they were also seen as caring about others.8
46 vs 61
self-ratings out of 100 by women and men with the same test score
Exley & Kessler, 2019
35% vs 73%
of women and men chose to compete, with no difference in performance
Niederle & Vesterlund, 2007
5 to 11%
of the gender gap in top jobs explained by men's overconfidence
Adamecz-Völgyi & Shure, 2022
+16%
higher likelihood of being hired when women do apply
LinkedIn, 2019

The practical conclusion. The useful question is not "how do I feel more confident?" but "am I judging my own work accurately, and does my environment reward confidence from me?" Women can correct for a known bias in self-assessment. Organisations can stop relying on self-assessment and self-nomination, which is where the gap does most damage. Section 08 turns this into specific steps.

02 Where the idea came from

The phrase entered mainstream business writing in 2014, when journalists Katty Kay and Claire Shipman published "The Confidence Gap" in The Atlantic and the book The Confidence Code.1 Their argument was that women's lower confidence, more than lower competence, explains part of why they advance more slowly.

The most memorable evidence they cited came from Hewlett-Packard. Women at the company were reported to apply for promotion only when they believed they met 100% of the listed qualifications, while men applied when they met about 60%.1 The figure spread widely, including through Sheryl Sandberg's Lean In and a 2019 LinkedIn report.2, 9 It has never been published as a study, and its method is unknown.

The best-known number in the confidence debate is also its least documented.

That matters because the claim carries a specific diagnosis: that the problem sits inside women and the solution is to change how they feel. Later research tested both parts of that diagnosis separately. The first part, a gap in self-assessment, holds up well. The second part, that it explains most of the career gap, does not.

03 What the evidence supports

A gap in self-evaluation

The strongest modern evidence comes from economists Christine Exley and Judd Kessler, who ran experiments with more than 4,000 online participants and more than 10,000 school-aged young people.3 In the first experiment reported in their working paper, women and men scored almost exactly the same on a maths and science test. Asked to rate how well they performed, men averaged 61 out of 100 and women 46.12

Actual scores and self-ratings by genderActual score (out of 20)010209.82Men9.96WomenSelf-rating: I performed well (0 to 100)05010061Men46Women
Actual scores and self-ratings
PanelGenderValue
Actual score (out of 20)Men9.82
Actual score (out of 20)Women9.96
Self-rating (0 to 100)Men61
Self-rating (0 to 100)Women46
Figure 1. Same performance, different self-rating. Actual test scores and self-ratings from the first experiment in Exley and Kessler's working paper. Women scored 9.96 and men 9.82 out of 20, a difference that was not statistically significant. Sources: references 3 and 12.

The gap persisted when incentives to self-promote were removed, and it appeared as early as the sixth grade. It did not appear when people rated their performance on a more female-typed task.3 That last detail is important. The gap is not a general lack of confidence; it is specific to domains coded as male, which includes much of technology.

A gap in choosing to compete

Choosing competition by genderMen73%Women35%0255075100Chose to be paid by competition rather than piece rate (no gender difference inperformance)
Choosing competition by gender
MeasureValue
Men73
Women35
Figure 2. Choosing competition. Share of participants who chose a tournament rather than a piece rate for their next task. Source: Niederle and Vesterlund (2007), reference 4.

Muriel Niederle and Lise Vesterlund asked participants to solve problems, first for a fixed rate per answer and then in a tournament. There were no gender differences in performance, yet 73% of men and 35% of women chose the tournament for the next round. The gap was driven partly by men's greater overconfidence and partly by different preferences for competing.4

A gap in self-esteem, larger in richer countries

A study of 985,937 people across 48 countries found men reported higher self-esteem than women in every age group.5 The gap was larger in individualistic, prosperous and more gender-equal countries, such as the United Kingdom, than in many Asian countries.13

A gap that narrows with age

Practitioner data points the same way. Zenger Folkman, a leadership consultancy, reports that women rate their own confidence lower than men under the age of 25, that the ratings converge around 40, and that women gain 29 percentile points in self-rated confidence between 25 and 60 or older, against 8.5 points for men.10 These figures come from a commercial self-assessment, not a peer-reviewed study.

Confidence gains with ageMen+8.5Women+29010203040Gain in self-rated confidence (percentile points), age 25 to 60+
Confidence gains with age
MeasureValue
Men8.5
Women29
Figure 3. Self-rated confidence gains with age. Practitioner data, not peer reviewed. Source: Zenger and Folkman (2019), reference 10.

04 Applying for jobs: the 60% and 100% claim

LinkedIn's behavioural data shows a real difference in how women and men apply. In its 2019 Gender Insights Report, women applied to 20% fewer jobs than men and were 16% less likely to apply after viewing a job. But when they did apply, women were 16% more likely to be hired, and 18% more likely for senior roles.9

Application and hiring rates indexed to menJobs applied to80Likelihood of applying after viewing a job84Likelihood of being hired after applying116Likelihood of being hired, senior roles118Men = 100020406080100120140Women, indexed to men = 100
Application and hiring rates indexed to men
MeasureValue
Jobs applied to80
Likelihood of applying after viewing a job84
Likelihood of being hired after applying116
Likelihood of being hired, senior roles118
Figure 4. Women's application and hiring rates, indexed to men. LinkedIn platform data. A value of 80 means 20% fewer than men; 116 means 16% more. Source: LinkedIn Gender Insights Report (2019), reference 9.

Applying less and succeeding more is consistent with women holding back from roles they could have won. But it does not show why. Tara Mohr tested that directly by asking more than 1,000 mostly American professionals why they had not applied for a job when they did not meet all the qualifications.2

Top reason for not applyingWomenMen
"I didn't think they would hire me since I didn't meet the qualifications, and I didn't want to waste my time and energy"40.6%46.4%
"I didn't think I could do the job well"About 10%About 12%

For both women and men, the main barrier was a belief about the hiring process, not doubt about ability. Mohr concluded that many people treat listed requirements as fixed when hiring managers often do not, so the fix is better information about how hiring works rather than more self-belief.2

05 How much does confidence explain?

If the confidence gap were the main cause of women's slower advancement, closing it should close most of the career gap. The evidence suggests it would close a small part.

Share of the top-job gap explained by overconfidence5% to 11% explained by men's greater overconfidenceRest of the gap0%25%50%75%100%Gender gap in holding a top job at age 42
Top-job gap explained by overconfidence
MeasureLower (%)Upper (%)
Explained by greater male overconfidence511
Figure 5. Share of the top-job gap explained by overconfidence. Longitudinal data following people from childhood to age 42. Source: Adamecz-Völgyi and Shure (2022), reference 7.

Anna Adamecz-Völgyi and Nikki Shure followed people from childhood into mid-career and built a measure of overconfidence by comparing tested ability with how people rated their own ability. They confirmed that men were more overconfident than women. That difference explained 5% to 11% of the gender gap in holding a top job at age 42: statistically significant, but small.7

The picture in engineering is sharper. A Stanford-led study followed 559 engineering and computer science graduates from more than two dozen US institutions between 2015 and 2017. Women and men left university with near-identical qualifications, but women earned about 9% less in their first jobs, with average salaries of $60,631 against $65,358 for men. A gap in engineering self-efficacy, meaning belief in one's own engineering ability, aligned with the pay gap. The authors found no difference in how much importance women and men placed on pay.6

Confidence matters at the margin. It is not the main reason so few women reach the top.

06 Confidence is judged differently

The popular advice assumes that if a woman behaves confidently, she will be rewarded as a man would be. The research says otherwise.

Laura Guillén, Margarita Mayo and Natalia Karelaia studied 236 highly skilled engineers at a multinational software company, using ratings from colleagues and supervisors over a year.8, 14 For both women and men, strong performance led to being seen as self-confident. For men, appearing self-confident then translated directly into influence in the organisation. For women it did not. High-performing women gained influence only when their confidence was combined with being seen as caring about others.8

This is the same pattern described in the companion review on the double bind. Women are judged on warmth as well as competence, and overt displays of dominance carry a penalty for women that they do not carry for men.15 Advice to "act more confident" can therefore backfire if it is read as advice to act more dominant.

What "be more confident" assumes

  • Women are less confident across the board
  • Confidence is the main barrier
  • Confidence is rewarded equally

What the evidence shows

  • The gap is mainly in self-assessment in male-typed domains
  • It explains a small share of career outcomes
  • Confidence turns into influence less directly for women

07 The critique of "fix the women"

Sociologists Shani Orgad and Rosalind Gill argue in Confidence Culture that the constant instruction to women to "believe in yourself" implies that psychological blocks, rather than entrenched social barriers, are what hold women back.11 On this view, confidence messaging can feel empowering while shifting responsibility for structural problems onto individuals.

The research reviewed here supports a balanced version of that critique. There is a measurable gap in self-assessment, and individuals can act on it. But the larger causes of slower advancement sit in how organisations hire, evaluate and promote, including how they respond when women do behave confidently. Treating confidence as the whole explanation risks spending effort on the smallest part of the problem.

08 What this means in practice

This section is practitioner guidance drawn from the research above and from coaching experience. It is not itself a research finding.

For women

  • Calibrate, do not inflate. Treat your first self-rating in technical areas as likely to be on the low side, and check it against evidence: results, metrics, peer feedback.
  • Write your self-review from data. List outcomes, numbers and decisions before you describe yourself. Let the record do the promoting.
  • Treat job requirements as a starting point. Most people who hold back do so because they think they will not be hired. If you meet the core of a role, apply and explain how you would cover the rest.
  • Ask before you rule yourself out. A short message to the hiring manager or recruiter asking which requirements are essential costs little.
  • Pair confidence with purpose. State your view firmly and say who it helps. The research suggests that combination carries further for women.

For managers and organisations

  • Do not rely on self-assessment for decisions. Equal performers rate themselves differently. Base ratings and promotions on evidence, not on how people describe themselves.
  • Do not rely on self-nomination. Invite people to apply for stretch roles and promotions, rather than waiting for them to put themselves forward.
  • Write job adverts with real requirements only. Separate essentials from nice-to-haves so capable applicants do not screen themselves out.
  • Reward confidence consistently. Notice whether the same assured behaviour earns a man influence and a woman a comment on her tone.

09 Method, limitations and how to cite

How this review was compiled

Sources were identified in November 2026 through searches of academic journals, working paper series, publisher records and original reports, prioritising peer-reviewed studies, large samples and research published since 2015. Findings are reported as their authors stated them. Where a figure comes from a working paper, a company report or practitioner data rather than a peer-reviewed article, this is marked in the text or references.

Limitations

This is a narrative review, not a systematic review, and it does not compute new estimates. "Confidence" is measured in different ways across studies, including self-ratings, self-esteem scales and comparisons between tested and estimated ability, so results are not directly comparable. Several sources are not peer reviewed, including the LinkedIn and Zenger Folkman data and the Hewlett-Packard figure, which has never been published. Most samples come from the United States and the United Kingdom.

How to cite this paper

Dulova, I. (2026). The confidence gap: What the evidence actually says (Her Success Coach Evidence Review No. 3). Her Success Coach. https://hersuccesscoach.com/research/confidence-gap

You are welcome to reproduce the figures with attribution and a link to the paper.

About the author

Iveta Dulova is an executive coach for women leaders, with a focus on technology, engineering and product. She has more than 14 years in technology, including as a Head of Product leading a team of product managers, and holds a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge. She is the author of Executive Presence, Decoded. Her Success Coach works with women leaders in the UK, North America, Australia and Singapore.

Holding back from a role you could win? A 30 minute Clarity Session (£20, credited in full if you go on to book coaching) can help you test the evidence for yourself.

10 References

1. Kay, K., & Shipman, C. (2014, May). The confidence gap. The Atlantic. See also Kay, K., & Shipman, C. (2014). The confidence code. HarperBusiness.

2. Mohr, T. S. (2014, August 25). Why women don't apply for jobs unless they're 100% qualified. Harvard Business Review.

3. Exley, C. L., & Kessler, J. B. (2022). The gender gap in self-promotion. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 137(3), 1345 to 1381. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjac003

4. Niederle, M., & Vesterlund, L. (2007). Do women shy away from competition? Do men compete too much? The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122(3), 1067 to 1101. https://doi.org/10.1162/qjec.122.3.1067

5. Bleidorn, W., Arslan, R. C., Denissen, J. J. A., Rentfrow, P. J., Gebauer, J. E., Potter, J., & Gosling, S. D. (2016). Age and gender differences in self-esteem: A cross-cultural window. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 111(3), 396 to 410. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspp0000078

6. Sterling, A. D., Thompson, M. E., Wang, S., Kusimo, A., Gilmartin, S., & Sheppard, S. (2020). The confidence gap predicts the gender pay gap among STEM graduates. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(48), 30303 to 30308. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2010269117

7. Adamecz-Völgyi, A., & Shure, N. (2022). The gender gap in top jobs: The role of overconfidence. Labour Economics, 79, 102283.

8. Guillén, L., Mayo, M., & Karelaia, N. (2018). Appearing self-confident and getting credit for it: Why it may be easier for men than women to gain influence at work. Human Resource Management, 57(4).

9. LinkedIn. (2019). Gender insights report: How women find jobs differently. LinkedIn Talent Solutions. (Company data, not peer reviewed.)

10. Zenger, J., & Folkman, J. (2019, June 25). Research: Women score higher than men in most leadership skills. Harvard Business Review. (Practitioner data, not peer reviewed.)

11. Orgad, S., & Gill, R. (2022). Confidence culture. Duke University Press.

12. Exley, C. L., & Kessler, J. B. (2019). The gender gap in self-promotion (NBER Working Paper No. 26345). National Bureau of Economic Research. https://doi.org/10.3386/w26345. Source for the self-ratings and scores in Figure 1.

13. American Psychological Association. (2016, January 4). Self-esteem gender gap more pronounced in Western countries. Press release on reference 5.

14. INSEAD. (2018). In the workplace, women only gain influence when they exhibit "feminine" behaviours. Summary of reference 8.

15. Williams, M. J., & Tiedens, L. Z. (2016). The subtle suspension of backlash: A meta-analysis of penalties for women's implicit and explicit dominance behavior. Psychological Bulletin, 142(2), 165 to 197. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000039