Definition
What is the glass cliff?
The glass cliff is the finding that women, and members of other under-represented groups, are sometimes more likely than men to be appointed to leadership roles when an organisation is already in difficulty, so the role carries a higher risk of failure. The term was introduced by Michelle Ryan and Alexander Haslam of the University of Exeter in 2005.1 Twenty years of research suggests the effect is real in some settings, such as politics and some executive appointments, and absent in others, including most large studies of company CEOs.8
About this paper. This is a narrative evidence review of peer-reviewed research on the glass cliff, the claim that women are more likely than men to be appointed to leadership roles when an organisation is in difficulty. It summarises published findings in plain English. It does not report new data. Every figure in the charts is taken from the cited study and can be checked against the reference list.
01 Executive summary
The glass cliff is one of the most quoted ideas in leadership. It is often presented as settled fact: when a company is failing, it hands the job to a woman. The research is more interesting than that, and more useful.
Five findings
- The effect is real in some settings and absent in others. The largest meta-analysis to date, covering 74 studies, found a small overall glass cliff effect in real appointments, concentrated in education, the non-profit sector and politics, with no detectable effect in business management.8
- In experiments, people do pick women more often for a crisis. Across leader selection experiments, the odds of choosing the woman for an organisation in crisis were about 1.45 times higher.8
- Large studies of company CEOs mostly find no glass cliff. Studies of US CEO appointments covering 1992 to 2022, and of large German and UK firms, found that women were not more likely to be appointed CEO in bad times. Some found the reverse.2, 7, 10, 11
- Below the CEO, crisis firms do appoint more women executives. A study of 26,156 US executive appointments found crisis firms were about 50% more likely to appoint a woman, mainly when the appointment could signal change to investors.9
- What happens after the appointment matters as much. One large US study found female CEOs were about 45% more likely to be dismissed, and that good performance protected men but not women.12 Another found female CEOs were 40% less likely to leave at any point.6 The evidence on this second test is as contested as the first.
The practical conclusion. A woman offered a turnaround role should not assume she is being set up to fail, and should not assume she is not. The question is not whether the glass cliff exists in general. It is whether this role has the resources, mandate and backing to succeed, and whether success will be judged fairly. Section 08 turns that into questions to ask before accepting.
02 Where the idea came from
In 2003, an article in The Times argued that companies with more women on their boards performed worse. Michelle Ryan and Alexander Haslam at the University of Exeter looked again at the same kind of data. They examined the share price performance of FTSE 100 companies before and after they appointed a new board member, comparing 19 appointments of women with 17 appointments of men.1, 15
Their finding reversed the story. During a general downturn in the stock market, companies that appointed women had tended to perform consistently poorly in the months before the appointment, while companies that appointed men had been relatively stable.1 Women were not causing the decline. They were being appointed into it. Ryan and Haslam named this pattern the glass cliff: a leadership position reached by breaking through the glass ceiling, but standing on a precarious edge.
The original claim was narrow: in one market, in one year, women joined boards of companies that were already struggling.
The idea spread quickly because it matched what many women had seen. High-profile appointments seemed to fit, and the term moved into business journalism and leadership training. Over the following two decades, researchers tested it in boardrooms, executive teams, elections, law firms, sport and laboratory experiments. The results, as the next sections show, point in more than one direction.
How the glass cliff has been tested
| Approach | What researchers do | Strength and weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Archival field studies | Compare real appointments of women and men against the organisation's performance beforehand, using share price, accounting returns or risk measures. | Real decisions, but hard to rule out other explanations. |
| Suitability experiments | Participants read about a thriving or struggling organisation and rate how suitable a male or female candidate is. | Clean comparison, but artificial setting. |
| Selection experiments | Participants choose between a male and a female candidate for the same role in good or bad times. | Measures choices, but not with real stakes. |
| Political studies | Compare how winnable the seats given to women and men candidates were. | Clear measure of risk, limited to party systems. |
03 Twenty years of studies, side by side
Figure 1 shows a selection of the most cited and most recent studies, coloured by what they found. It is chosen to show the range of settings, not to be complete.
| Year | Author | Sample | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2005 | Ryan & Haslam | FTSE 100 board appointments, UK | Finds a glass cliff |
| 2009 | Adams, Gupta & Leeth | US CEO appointments, 1992 to 2004 | Finds no glass cliff |
| 2010 | Bruckmüller & Branscombe | Two leader selection experiments | Finds a glass cliff |
| 2010 | Ryan, Haslam & Kulich | UK 2005 general election candidates | Finds a glass cliff |
| 2014 | Cook & Glass | Fortune 500 CEO transitions, 15 years | Finds a glass cliff |
| 2018 | Elsaid & Ursel | 193 female CEOs, North America | Mixed or conditional |
| 2019 | Bechtoldt, Bannier & Rock | 233 listed firms, Germany and UK | Finds no glass cliff |
| 2020 | Morgenroth et al. | Meta-analysis of 74 studies | Mixed or conditional |
| 2023 | Reinwald, Zaia & Kunze | 26,156 US executive appointments | Finds a glass cliff |
| 2025 | Li et al. | 10,348 US CEO appointments | Finds no glass cliff |
| 2026 | He & Whited | US CEO successions, 2001 to 2019 | Finds no glass cliff |
Two patterns stand out. First, support is strongest in politics, experiments and broad executive appointments. In the 2005 UK general election, Conservative women contested harder to win seats than Conservative men, while Labour showed no gender difference.4 In experiments, participants chose a woman to lead a struggling company when its previous leaders had been men, and the preference disappeared when its previous leaders had been women.3
Second, the largest studies focused on chief executives in listed companies have mostly not found the effect. Adams, Gupta and Leeth found that across US CEO appointments from 1992 to 2004, prior performance tended to favour women, meaning women were appointed when firms were in relatively better health.2 Li and colleagues reached a similar conclusion with 10,348 US CEO appointments, including 526 women, from 1998 to 2022.10 He and Whited, modelling US CEO successions, found no evidence of a glass cliff and identified a shortage of suitable female candidates, rather than board reluctance, as the main constraint.11
Against these, Cook and Glass analysed every CEO transition in the Fortune 500 over 15 years and found that white women and people of colour were more likely than white men to be promoted to CEO of weakly performing firms.5 In a separate analysis covering 20 years, the same authors found that diversity among decision makers, rather than firm performance, was what raised women's chances of promotion.16 The answer depends on the question asked.
04 What the meta-analysis found
A meta-analysis pools studies to estimate the overall effect and test what explains the differences. In 2020, Morgenroth, Kirby, Ryan and Sudkämper published three meta-analyses in Psychological Bulletin, combining 91 independent samples from 74 studies: 33 archival and 58 experimental.8
| Study type | Estimate | Lower CI | Upper CI | Measure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Archival field studies (real appointments) | 0.07 | 0.001 | 0.13 | Hedges' g |
| Suitability ratings, between participants | 0.32 | 0.1 | 0.54 | Hedges' g |
| Suitability ratings, within participants | 0.07 | -0.02 | 0.15 | Hedges' g |
| Leader selection experiments | 1.45 | 1.17 | 1.78 | Odds ratio |
The headline: small, real and dependent on context
In real appointments the effect was small, with a pooled effect size of 0.07. Its size depended on the sector. Effects were more substantial in education and the non-profit sector, smaller in politics, and not detectable in management, the very domain where the glass cliff was first described, or in sport.8
Experiments told a stronger story. When different participants rated a candidate for a thriving or a struggling organisation, women were rated as more suitable for the crisis role, with an effect size of 0.32. When the same participants rated both situations, the effect disappeared. In selection experiments, the odds of choosing the woman in a crisis were 1.45 times higher, and this effect was larger in countries with greater gender inequality.8
What the meta-analysis supported
- A small glass cliff in real appointments overall
- A clear preference for women in crisis selection experiments
- Larger effects where gender inequality is higher
- A similar pattern for members of under-represented racial and ethnic groups
What it did not support
- A glass cliff in business management appointments
- The idea that crises call for stereotypically feminine leaders, often summarised as "think crisis, think female"
- Much risk of publication bias: unusually, 40% to 75% of samples were unpublished work
On why the effect occurs, the authors found weak support for a signalling explanation: the effect was strongest when the previous leader's gender was unknown, consistent with appointing a woman as a visible sign of change.8 That idea became the focus of the next major study.
05 Why the studies disagree
Disagreement in this literature is not a sign that the research is weak. It is a sign that "the glass cliff" bundles together several different questions. Studies reach different answers because they measure different things.
| Source of difference | Why it changes the answer |
|---|---|
| Which role | Board seats, CEO roles and other executive roles are filled by different people for different reasons. Large CEO studies tend to find no effect.2, 10, 11 A large study of executive appointments below and including the CEO found one.9 |
| How "precarious" is measured | Share price trends, accounting returns, volatility and default risk can rank the same firm differently. Li and colleagues tested several measures and found no clear evidence on any of them.10 |
| Country and period | The UK FTSE data of 2003 came from a falling market. A study of 233 large German and UK firms from 2005 to 2015 found no glass cliff, and in Germany investors reacted positively when a struggling firm appointed a woman.7, 17 |
| Real choices or experiments | Experiments show what people prefer when everything else is equal. Real appointments are shaped by who is available, who is already on the shortlist and who the board knows.8, 11 |
| Conditions around the appointment | The effect may only appear when an appointment can be read as a signal of change.9 |
The signalling study
Reinwald, Zaia and Kunze examined 26,156 executive appointments at almost 4,000 US public companies from 2000 to 2016. By comparing firms just inside and just outside a definition of crisis, they could isolate the effect of the crisis itself. Firms in crisis were about 50% more likely to appoint a female executive.9, 18
The effect depended on three conditions: when the firm had no other female executive, on the type of appointment, and on how much attention investors were paying. Crisis firms were also more likely to describe female appointments as change in their press releases.9 This points to a specific mechanism. In some cases, appointing a woman is used as a visible message to the market that the company is changing.
The most defensible version of the glass cliff is conditional: in some roles, in some sectors, under some conditions, women are more likely to be handed the hard job.
06 After the appointment: the second test
A glass cliff has two parts: being appointed to a precarious role, and then falling from it. Even where the first part is absent, the second can still apply. Research here is also divided.
| Study and measure | Relative likelihood | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Gupta et al. (2020), likelihood of dismissal, US CEOs | 1.45 | 1.45 (about 45% higher) |
| Elsaid & Ursel (2018), likelihood of leaving at any point | 0.6 | 0.60 (about 40% lower) |
Evidence that women fall harder
Gupta and colleagues found that female CEOs were about 45% more likely than male CEOs to be dismissed. Strong firm performance made men less likely to be dismissed, but did not protect women in the same way.12, 19 Cook, Glass and Ingersoll found that women CEOs had a higher risk of dismissal, and that this gap widened when women had been appointed during weak performance.14 Cook and Glass also described a "saviour effect": when firms led by women or people of colour struggled, they tended to be replaced by white men.5 In UK boardrooms, Main and Gregory-Smith found that women directors faced a sharp rise in exit risk as they approached nine years of service, when they lose their independent status.13
Evidence that they do not
Elsaid and Ursel found that women were appointed CEO in riskier situations, consistent with the first part of the glass cliff, but were then 40% less likely to face turnover at any point.6 The authors suggested that firms may be reluctant to attract negative publicity by removing a female CEO.20
What this means. The risk of a short or harshly judged tenure is not proven to be universal, but it is well enough documented that it should shape how a woman negotiates a senior role and how a board evaluates one.
07 The better evidenced problem: the ceiling
Several authors who found no glass cliff were clear that their findings do not mean the barrier to women's leadership has gone. The authors of the German and UK study concluded that the glass ceiling persists.7, 17 He and Whited's model points to a shortage of women in the candidate pool as the main reason so few women become CEOs.11 The current figures support that emphasis.
| Role | Women as percentage |
|---|---|
| FTSE 350 board seats | 43% |
| Fortune 500 CEOs | 11% |
| FTSE 350 CEOs | 8% |
| Fortune Global 500 CEOs | 6.8% |
The contrast in the UK is the clearest. Women now hold 43% of FTSE 350 board seats, yet only 8% of FTSE 350 chief executives are women.21 In the United States, a record 55 women led Fortune 500 companies in 2026, about 11% of the list.22 Globally, 34 women ran Fortune Global 500 companies, or 6.8%.23
The glass cliff debate is about the conditions under which the few women who reach the top are appointed. The numbers above are a reminder that the larger problem is how few reach that point at all, and that the pipeline into executive roles, not only the moment of appointment, is where most of the loss happens.
08 What this means in practice
This section is practitioner guidance drawn from the research above and from coaching experience. It is not itself a research finding.
Because the evidence is conditional, the useful question for an individual is not "is the glass cliff real?" but "what are the conditions of this particular role?" The research suggests which conditions matter: how precarious the situation is, whether the appointment is being used as a signal, what support exists, and how performance will be judged.
For a woman offered a turnaround or high-risk role
- Diagnose the starting point. Ask for the numbers that describe the problem, and agree in writing what the baseline is, so you are measured on progress from where you started.
- Ask why you, and why now. If the answer is mainly about signalling change, ask what change the board expects you to deliver and what it will fund.
- Agree the mandate and resources before you accept. Authority over your team, budget and timeline matters more in a crisis than in a steady role.
- Name your sponsor on the board. Find out who will back you publicly when results take time.
- Agree how success will be judged, and when. Turnarounds take longer than steady roles. Agree interim measures that reflect that.
- Negotiate the exit terms. Severance and notice terms are part of pricing the risk, not a sign of doubt.
- Do not turn down the role on the basis of the metaphor alone. Some of the research finds women stay longer once appointed, and crisis roles can be where reputations are made.
For boards, chairs and nomination committees
- Build the pipeline early. If the shortlist only becomes diverse in a crisis, the appointment will look like a signal whatever the intention.
- Judge leaders on trajectory, not inherited results. Evaluate performance against the position the leader started from.
- Check for asymmetric patience. The dismissal research suggests strong performance protects men more than women. Ask whether the same results would lead to the same decision for a different leader.
- Avoid the reflex to replace with a "safe" profile. The saviour effect describes a pattern, not a strategy.
09 Method, limitations and how to cite
How this review was compiled
Studies were identified in November 2026 through searches for glass cliff research in academic journals, publisher records and university repositories, with priority given to peer-reviewed articles, the most cited early studies, the 2020 meta-analysis and studies published since 2020. Findings are reported as their authors stated them. Where a figure comes from a university press release or an author summary rather than the article itself, this is marked in the references.
Limitations
This is a narrative review, not a systematic review. It does not include every study on the topic and does not compute new pooled estimates. Most archival evidence comes from the United States and the United Kingdom, and from listed companies. Research on technology firms specifically is limited, so conclusions for that sector are drawn by extension from broader samples.
How to cite this paper
You are welcome to reproduce the figures with attribution and a link to the paper.
About the author
Iveta Dulova is an executive coach for women leaders, with a focus on technology, engineering and product. She has more than 14 years in technology, including as a Head of Product leading a team of product managers, and holds a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge. She is the author of Executive Presence, Decoded. Her Success Coach works with women leaders in the UK, North America, Australia and Singapore.
10 References
1. Ryan, M. K., & Haslam, S. A. (2005). The glass cliff: Evidence that women are over-represented in precarious leadership positions. British Journal of Management, 16(2), 81 to 90. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8551.2005.00433.x
2. Adams, S. M., Gupta, A., & Leeth, J. D. (2009). Are female executives over-represented in precarious leadership positions? British Journal of Management, 20(1), 1 to 12. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8551.2007.00549.x
3. Bruckmüller, S., & Branscombe, N. R. (2010). The glass cliff: When and why women are selected as leaders in crisis contexts. British Journal of Social Psychology, 49(3), 433 to 451. https://doi.org/10.1348/014466609X466594
4. Ryan, M. K., Haslam, S. A., & Kulich, C. (2010). Politics and the glass cliff: Evidence that women are preferentially selected to contest hard-to-win seats. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 34(1), 56 to 64. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-6402.2009.01541.x
5. Cook, A., & Glass, C. (2014). Above the glass ceiling: When are women and racial/ethnic minorities promoted to CEO? Strategic Management Journal, 35(7), 1080 to 1089. https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2161
6. Elsaid, E., & Ursel, N. D. (2018). Re-examining the glass cliff hypothesis using survival analysis: The case of female CEO tenure. British Journal of Management, 29. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12241
7. Bechtoldt, M. N., Bannier, C. E., & Rock, B. (2019). The glass cliff myth? Evidence from Germany and the U.K. The Leadership Quarterly, 30(3), 273 to 297. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2018.11.004
8. Morgenroth, T., Kirby, T. A., Ryan, M. K., & Sudkämper, A. (2020). The who, when, and why of the glass cliff phenomenon: A meta-analysis of appointments to precarious leadership positions. Psychological Bulletin, 146(9), 797 to 829. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000234
9. Reinwald, M., Zaia, J., & Kunze, F. (2023). Shine bright like a diamond: When signaling creates glass cliffs for female executives. Journal of Management, 49(3), 1005 to 1036. https://doi.org/10.1177/01492063211067518
10. Li, X., Moyer, O., Pfeiffer, O., Velthuis, R., & Zaleski, P. (2025). Female CEO selection: Does the glass cliff exist? The Leadership Quarterly. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2024.101853
11. He, L., & Whited, T. M. (2026). Underrepresentation of women CEOs. The Review of Financial Studies (advance article). https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/hhag077
12. Gupta, V. K., Mortal, S. C., Silveri, S., Sun, M., & Turban, D. B. (2020). You're fired! Gender disparities in CEO dismissal. Journal of Management, 46(4).
13. Main, B. G. M., & Gregory-Smith, I. (2018). Symbolic management and the glass cliff: Evidence from the boardroom careers of female and male directors. British Journal of Management, 29(1), 136 to 155. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12208
14. Cook, A., Glass, C., & Ingersoll, A. (2024). Leading while female: Analyzing women CEOs' post-appointment trajectory. Social Science Quarterly, 105(7), 2080 to 2092.
15. University of Exeter. (2021). Discovering the glass cliff: Insights into subtle gender discrimination in the workplace. Research Excellence Framework impact case study. (Source for appointment counts.)
16. Cook, A., & Glass, C. (2014). Women and top leadership positions: Towards an institutional analysis. Gender, Work & Organization, 21(1), 91 to 103.
17. EurekAlert. (2018, December 12). New research questions the "glass cliff" and corroborates the persistent "glass ceiling". Press release on reference 7.
18. University of Konstanz. (2022, March 17). On the glass cliff: Women in leadership at crisis-ridden companies. Press release on reference 9.
19. University of Alabama Culverhouse College of Business. (2018). Even if doing a good job, women CEOs more likely to be fired. Press release on reference 12.
20. Elsaid, E., & Ursel, N. (2018). Who stays longer, male or female CEOs? LSE Business Review. Author summary of reference 6.
21. FTSE Women Leaders Review. (2026, February). Achieving gender balance. 2025 report, published 24 February 2026.
22. Fortune. (2026, June 3). Women run a record 11% of Fortune 500 companies in 2026.
23. Fortune. (2026, August 3). A record 34 women now run Fortune Global 500 companies.