How to Get Honest Feedback on Your Executive Presence

Told you need more executive presence? How to turn vague feedback into specific behaviours: whom to ask, what to ask, and scripts for your manager.

Her Success Coach helps women leaders build confidence, overcome self-doubt, and lead with clarity. Cambridge-trained, evidence-based coaching for senior women in tech, business, and finance.

"You need more executive presence" is one of the most common, and least useful, pieces of feedback senior women receive. It sounds important, it may be holding back a promotion, and it rarely comes with a single concrete example.

This guide shows you how to turn vague presence feedback into something specific you can act on: whom to ask, what to ask, and what to do with the answers.

Why presence feedback is so vague

There are three reasons people struggle to tell you what they mean.

  • Presence is a judgement, not a behaviour. People form an impression and then reach for a label. They often have not worked out which behaviours created the impression.
  • It feels personal. Comments about how someone speaks, carries themselves or dresses feel risky, so people retreat into general words.
  • Women get less of it. Sylvia Ann Hewlett's research on executive presence found that specific feedback on presence is hard to come by, and harder still for women. That means many women hear the conclusion without the evidence.

The result is a label that feels like a verdict, with no route to change it. The fix is to ask better questions, of more people, about specific moments.

Step 1: Decide what you want feedback on

Executive presence is usually described in three parts: gravitas (how you act), communication (how you speak) and appearance (how you look). See our guide to Sylvia Hewlett's executive presence model for the background.

Rather than ask about all of it, pick the situations that matter most for your next role, for example:

  • Presenting a recommendation to the leadership team
  • Holding your position when challenged in a meeting
  • Running a difficult conversation with a peer
  • Speaking first, briefly, in a large group

Step 2: Choose the right people

Ask four to six people who have seen you in those situations. Aim for a mix:

  • Your manager, who will be part of the promotion decision.
  • One or two people more senior than your manager, who see you less often but whose impression counts.
  • Two peers who see you in meetings you share.
  • One person you trust to be candid, inside or outside your organisation.

Avoid asking only people who like you. Kind feedback is pleasant, but it rarely tells you what is happening in the room.

Step 3: Ask about moments, not traits

The single most useful change you can make is to ask about a specific recent moment, not about your presence in general.

Instead of: "How's my executive presence?"

Ask: "In Tuesday's budget review, when the CFO challenged the forecast, how did my answer come across? What would have made it land more strongly?"

Some other questions that work well:

  • "When I present to the leadership team, what's the one thing I do that most helps, and the one thing that most gets in the way?"
  • "Is there a meeting recently where you thought I could have spoken up earlier, or held my ground more?"
  • "When you hear me give a recommendation, do I sound like I'm proposing or asking for permission?"
  • "If you were advising me on how to come across at the next level, what would you tell me to start, stop and keep doing?"
  • "What do the people who come across with presence here do that I don't?"

Step 4: When someone gives you a label, ask for the example

You will still hear labels. Each one is a doorway to a better question.

You hear Ask
"You need more gravitas." "Could you think of a moment where I could have shown it? What would it have looked like?"
"You need to be more confident." "Is it what I say, or how I say it? Could you give me an example?"
"You're a bit too detailed." "In which meeting did that come across most? What would the shorter version have been?"
"You need to be more visible." "Visible to whom, specifically, and in which forums?"
"You don't come across as senior yet." "Who do you think does come across as senior here, and what do they do differently?"

Step 5: Look for patterns, not verdicts

After four to six conversations, write down every specific example you heard. Then look for patterns.

  • Repeated themes across different people are worth acting on.
  • One-off comments may say more about the person than about you.
  • Contradictions, such as "be more assertive" from one person and "be less direct" from another, often point to the double standard women face. Note them, and discuss them with your manager.

Choose one or two behaviours to work on, not ten. Common, high-value ones include:

  • Leading with your recommendation, then the reasons, rather than building up to it. See how to stop over-explaining at work.
  • Speaking in the first ten minutes of important meetings. See how to speak up in meetings as a woman.
  • Handling challenge without retreating. See how to speak with authority in high-stakes meetings.

Step 6: Close the loop

Feedback becomes far more useful when you go back to people.

"Thank you for your feedback last month about leading with my recommendation. I've been trying it in the leadership meeting. Have you noticed a difference, and is there anything else you'd suggest?"

This does two things. It gives you a second round of specific feedback, and it shows senior people that you act on what they say, which is itself a signal of presence.

Scripts to use with your manager

Asking for specifics:

"You mentioned I need more executive presence before the next level. I want to work on it seriously. Could we pick two situations where it matters most, and could you tell me what you'd want to see from me in each?"

Raising a contradiction:

"I've had feedback that I should be more assertive, and also that I can come across as too direct. I'd value your help in working out what the right balance looks like here."

Agreeing how you'll know it has changed:

"If I work on these two things over the next three months, how will we know it's working? Could we check in after the next leadership review?"

The short version

Vague presence feedback is common, and it is not a verdict. Ask more people about specific moments, turn labels into examples, look for patterns, work on one or two behaviours, then go back and ask again.

For a structured way to work on presence day to day, read our step-by-step guide to developing executive presence, or the book Executive Presence, Decoded. If you would like help turning feedback into a plan, see executive presence coaching.

Source: Hewlett, S. A. (2014), Executive Presence: The Missing Link Between Merit and Success; Center for Talent Innovation (now Coqual), Executive Presence key findings.


This guide is part of our series on executive presence. See all the guides, and how one-to-one support works, on our executive presence coaching page.

Continue reading

  • Executive Presence Feedback Statistics: What the Research Shows for Women in Tech
  • The Executive Presence Feedback Translator: Twelve Vague Phrases and the Behaviour Behind Them
  • Executive Presence for Engineers and Technical Leaders: Fixing "Gets Into the Weeds"

What you will find here

This page is part of the Her Success Coach resource library — a collection of practical articles, frameworks, and coaching programmes designed for women leaders. Explore in-depth guides on leadership confidence, career transitions, executive presence, imposter syndrome, delegation, strategic thinking, and difficult conversations at work. Book a 30-minute Clarity Session to discuss your goals, or join an on-demand course to develop the skills you need at your own pace.

About Her Success Coach

Iveta Dulova is an executive and leadership coach for women with a decade of experience in global technology and a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge. She works with women managers, directors, and founders across technology, financial services, and consulting who want to build executive presence, negotiate with confidence, and build a career that reflects their values rather than their fears.

Explore more

  • Home
  • About Iveta
  • Coaching services
  • Articles and resources
  • Book a Clarity Session
  • The Confident Leader course
  • Contact

Online executive coaching for clients in London, Toronto, Singapore and Sydney.

Research