Key figures on executive presence feedback and performance reviews for women in tech, with sources: vague feedback, personality criticism and what it costs.
Her Success Coach helps women leaders build confidence, overcome self-doubt, and lead with clarity. Cambridge-trained, evidence-based coaching for senior women in tech, business, and finance.
Women in technology receive feedback that is more often about personality, less often tied to business results, and harder to act on. This page collects the most cited figures in one place, with the source and sample for each, so you can quote them accurately.
| Finding | Figure | Source and sample |
|---|---|---|
| Senior executives who name gravitas as the core of executive presence | 67 per cent | Center for Talent Innovation (now Coqual), 2012, 268 senior executives |
| Senior executives who name communication | 28 per cent | Same survey |
| Senior executives who name appearance | 5 per cent | Same survey |
| Women and people of colour who are unclear how to act on executive presence feedback | 81 per cent | Same research programme, survey of nearly 4,000 professionals |
| Professionals who have had executive presence feedback from a male superior | 32 per cent of women, 47 per cent of men | Same research programme |
| Critical reviews containing negative personality criticism | 71 of 94 for women, 2 of 83 for men | Kieran Snyder, 2014, 248 reviews from 28 technology companies |
| Reviews containing vague praise | 57 per cent for women, 43 per cent for men | Correll and Simard, Stanford, 2016, about 200 reviews at a large technology company |
| Developmental feedback linked to business outcomes | 60 per cent for men, 40 per cent for women | Same study |
| Likelihood of receiving personality feedback | Women 22 per cent more likely than men | Textio, 2024, more than 23,000 reviews at 250 United States organisations |
| People who recall being described as "emotional" | 78 per cent of women, 11 per cent of men | Textio, 2024, worker survey |
| Extra likelihood of leaving within a year after low quality feedback | 63 per cent | Textio, 2023 |
| Women who are often the only woman in the room | One in five overall, around 40 per cent of senior women and women in technical roles | Women in the Workplace 2018, more than 64,000 employees |
| Employees with a sponsor at entry level | 31 per cent of women, 45 per cent of men | Women in the Workplace 2025 |
The most quoted research comes from Sylvia Ann Hewlett and the Center for Talent Innovation. In 2012 the team asked 268 senior executives what signals leadership potential. Gravitas, meaning how you act, came first for 67 per cent. Communication came second at 28 per cent. Appearance came last at 5 per cent.
Within gravitas, the behaviour named most often was confidence and composure under pressure, chosen by 79 per cent when the leader in question was a woman. Decisiveness followed at 70 per cent, then integrity and candour with leaders at 64 per cent.
So when someone says "presence", the evidence suggests they are mostly talking about judgement and steadiness, and only slightly about how you look.
The same research programme found that feedback on executive presence often contradicts itself for women and people of colour, and that 81 per cent of them were unclear how to act on it. Women were also less likely to hear it from the people with most influence: 32 per cent had received presence feedback from a male superior, against 47 per cent of men.
That combination matters. The feedback carries weight in promotion decisions, and the person receiving it often cannot tell what to change.
Three studies of written reviews in technology companies point the same way.
Personality criticism. In 2014 the linguist Kieran Snyder collected 248 reviews from 28 technology companies. Among reviews that contained criticism, 71 of 94 written about women included negative comments on personality, such as being told to watch their tone. The same was true of 2 of 83 written about men.
Vague praise. Shelley Correll and Caroline Simard at Stanford analysed about 200 reviews from a large technology company. Vague praise such as "you had a great year" appeared in 57 per cent of women's reviews and 43 per cent of men's. Feedback that linked development to business outcomes appeared in 60 per cent of men's reviews and 40 per cent of women's.
Same behaviour, different reading. A later Stanford study, published in the American Sociological Review in 2020, coded managers' written reviews at a Fortune 500 technology company. Men and women were equally likely to be described as technically able. The differences appeared in comments on personality, future potential and who counted as exceptional. Women were more often seen as too aggressive, and taking charge was valued more highly in men's ratings.
Ten years after her first study, Snyder's company Textio analysed more than 23,000 reviews written at 250 organisations in the United States. Women were 22 per cent more likely than men to receive feedback about personality. In the accompanying worker survey, 78 per cent of women remembered being described as "emotional", against 11 per cent of men. High performing men were far more often praised as confident or ambitious than high performing women.
Textio's 2023 research adds a cost for employers. People who received low quality feedback, meaning feedback that is not specific, relevant or actionable, were 63 per cent more likely to leave within a year.
Her Success Coach (2026). Executive presence feedback statistics: what the research shows for women in tech. hersuccesscoach.com. Please also credit the original study for any figure you use.
Next step: Take the free Presence Self-Assessment. It takes about ten minutes and shows which of eight dimensions to work on first.
Iveta Dulova is an executive coach accredited by the Association for Coaching and the founder of Her Success Coach. She holds a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge and spent more than fourteen years in software engineering and product leadership.
This guide is part of our series on executive presence. See all the guides, and how one-to-one support works, on our executive presence coaching page.
This page is part of the Her Success Coach resource library — a collection of practical articles, frameworks, and coaching programmes designed for women leaders. Explore in-depth guides on leadership confidence, career transitions, executive presence, imposter syndrome, delegation, strategic thinking, and difficult conversations at work. Book a 30-minute Clarity Session to discuss your goals, or join an on-demand course to develop the skills you need at your own pace.
Iveta Dulova is an executive and leadership coach for women with a decade of experience in global technology and a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge. She works with women managers, directors, and founders across technology, financial services, and consulting who want to build executive presence, negotiate with confidence, and build a career that reflects their values rather than their fears.
Online executive coaching for clients in London, Toronto, Singapore and Sydney.