How to Give Executive Presence Feedback: A Guide for Managers and HR

About to tell someone they need more executive presence? A five-step method for managers and HR that turns an impression into feedback people can act on.

Her Success Coach helps women leaders build confidence, overcome self-doubt, and lead with clarity. Cambridge-trained, evidence-based coaching for senior women in tech, business, and finance.

If you manage talented people, at some point you will form the view that one of them is not yet coming across as senior. You may be right. The difficulty is the next step. "You need more executive presence" passes on your conclusion and keeps the evidence to yourself.

Why this matters

Most people cannot act on it. Research by the Center for Talent Innovation found that 81 per cent of women and people of colour who had received executive presence feedback were unclear how to act on it.

It is not given evenly. Stanford researchers analysing about 200 reviews at a large technology company found vague praise in 57 per cent of women's reviews and 43 per cent of men's, and development advice linked to business outcomes in 60 per cent of men's and 40 per cent of women's. In experiments by Lily Jampol and Vivian Zayas, people gave an underperforming woman kinder and less accurate feedback than an equally underperforming man.

Vague feedback costs you people. Textio's 2023 research found that employees who received low quality feedback were 63 per cent more likely to leave within a year.

Managers know the process is weak. In one project described by Stanford's Lori Mackenzie, JoAnne Wehner and Shelley Correll, only 15 per cent of women managers and 24 per cent of men managers had confidence in the performance evaluation process.

Five steps before you say "presence"

1. Find the moment. Which meeting, which audience, what kind of situation? If you cannot name one, you are not ready to give the feedback. Watch for two weeks first.

2. Describe what a camera would have recorded. "When the chief financial officer asked whether we were on track, you spoke for about two minutes before giving the answer." That is behaviour. "You lack gravitas" is a verdict.

3. Name the impact on the work. "The decision moved to email and took another week." Impact tells the person whether the change is worth making, and it keeps the conversation about results.

4. Run the comparison check. Ask yourself whether you would give the same feedback, in the same words, to a colleague of a different gender who did the same thing. Stanford's study of reviews at a Fortune 500 technology company found the largest gender differences in comments about personality, potential and exceptional performance. If your note contains a personality word, replace it with the behaviour.

5. Agree an experiment and a date. "For the next four leadership meetings, lead with your recommendation. I'll give you one line of feedback after each."

Words to replace

Instead of Say
"More gravitas" "When challenged by the chief executive, you changed your recommendation without new information."
"Too in the weeds" "Your update covered implementation for five minutes before the decision you needed."
"Be more confident" "You began your recommendation with 'I might be wrong'. Start with the recommendation."
"Abrasive" "In Tuesday's review you said 'that's obviously wrong' and two people stopped contributing."
"Not strategic" "Your plan covers your team's deliverables. I'd like to see the effect on revenue and on the sales team."

What to do at team level

  • Agree the criteria for the next level before review season and use the same criteria for everyone. The Stanford researchers found that agreeing criteria first reduces reliance on stereotypes.
  • Read a sample of last year's reviews. Count personality words and praise with no example, by gender.
  • Give the people you are developing the hard feedback as well as the kind feedback. Protective vagueness leaves the judgement in place and removes the means to change it.
  • Make sure presence feedback comes with sponsorship. Women in the Workplace 2025 found that 31 per cent of entry level women had a sponsor, against 45 per cent of men.

For the full set of figures, see our executive presence feedback statistics.

When coaching helps

Coaching is useful once the behaviour is clear and the person wants a structured place to practise. It works best when the manager has done the five steps first, the goals are agreed between the three of you, and the content of sessions stays confidential.

Next step: Share the executive presence feedback translator with the person you are developing. For one-to-one support for women leaders, see executive presence coaching.

Sources

  • Center for Talent Innovation (2012). Executive Presence: key findings. coqual.org
  • Correll, S. and Simard, C. (2016). Research: Vague feedback is holding women back. Harvard Business Review, 29 April 2016.
  • Jampol, L. and Zayas, V. (2021). Gendered white lies. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 47(1), 57 to 69.
  • Textio (2023). Language Bias in Performance Feedback 2023. textio.com
  • Mackenzie, L., Wehner, J. and Correll, S. (2019). Why most performance evaluations are biased, and how to fix them. Harvard Business Review. Stanford summary
  • Correll, S. J., Weisshaar, K. R., Wynn, A. T. and Wehner, J. D. (2020). Inside the black box of organizational life. American Sociological Review, 85(6). Stanford summary
  • LeanIn.Org and McKinsey and Company (2025). Women in the Workplace 2025

This guide is part of our series on executive presence. See all the guides, and how one-to-one support works, on our executive presence coaching page.

Continue reading

  • How to Influence Without Authority: A Practical Guide for Women Leaders
  • How to Move From Technical Expert to Strategic Leader
  • How to Stop Over-Explaining at Work (and Get to the Point)

What you will find here

This page is part of the Her Success Coach resource library — a collection of practical articles, frameworks, and coaching programmes designed for women leaders. Explore in-depth guides on leadership confidence, career transitions, executive presence, imposter syndrome, delegation, strategic thinking, and difficult conversations at work. Book a 30-minute Clarity Session to discuss your goals, or join an on-demand course to develop the skills you need at your own pace.

About Her Success Coach

Iveta Dulova is an executive and leadership coach for women with a decade of experience in global technology and a Diploma in Coaching and Leadership from the University of Cambridge. She works with women managers, directors, and founders across technology, financial services, and consulting who want to build executive presence, negotiate with confidence, and build a career that reflects their values rather than their fears.

Explore more

  • Home
  • About Iveta
  • Coaching services
  • Articles and resources
  • Book a Clarity Session
  • The Confident Leader course
  • Contact

Online executive coaching for clients in London, Toronto, Singapore and Sydney.

Research